Ceremonial cacao is the whole, full-fat mass of ground cacao beans. Ordinary cocoa powder is the same mass after most of the fat has been pressed out, and it is often alkalised as well. That is where the differences in taste, thickness and price come from.
Ceremonial cacao, cocoa powder, drinking chocolate and dark chocolate stand side by side on the shelves. They all come from the same bean, but they are four different products. Below we show how they differ and how to recognise them from the ingredients.
How is each of these products made?
The starting point is always the same. Cacao beans ferment, dry, are roasted and ground into a thick paste called cacao mass. From there the paths go separate ways.
- Ceremonial cacao: the cacao mass sets into blocks or flakes. Nothing is taken out of it.
- Cocoa powder: the mass is pressed to separate the cacao butter. The hard cake left behind is milled into powder.
- Drinking chocolate: cocoa powder or cacao mass is mixed with sugar, often with milk powder and flavourings.
- Dark chocolate: cacao mass is combined with sugar and extra cacao butter, then mixed for a long time and tempered.
The press for separating cacao butter was patented in 1828 by the Dutchman Coenraad van Houten. His name and country gave rise to the term Dutch cocoa, meaning alkalised cocoa.
Comparison table
| Feature | Ceremonial cacao | Cocoa powder | Drinking chocolate | Dark chocolate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | 100% cacao mass | Defatted cocoa | Sugar, cocoa, often milk powder | Cacao mass, sugar, cacao butter |
| Fat | About half of the mass | Usually 10 to 22% | Depends on the recipe | About 30 to 45% |
| Form | Block, disc, flakes | Loose powder | Powder or granules | Bar |
| Taste | Deep, bitter, full | Flat, dry | Sweet | Bittersweet |
| Texture of the drink | Thick, velvety | Thin | Creamy, sweet | Thick when melted |
| Best use | Drink, ceremony | Baking | Quick drink | Eating, desserts |
What is alkalised cocoa?
Alkalisation means treating cocoa with an alkaline solution. The powder darkens, loses its acidity and dissolves more easily in liquid. In exchange, its taste becomes milder and less complex.
On the package you can recognise it by words such as "alkalised" or "processed with alkali", or by E501 or E525 in the ingredients. Ceremonial cacao is not alkalised.
What does research say about alkalising cocoa?
Scientists have measured the difference between natural and alkalised cocoa. In 2008 a team led by Kenneth Miller at the Hershey laboratory published an analysis of popular cocoa powders in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. Natural, non-alkalised powders had the most flavanols and polyphenols and the highest antioxidant capacity. The more heavily the cocoa was alkalised, the fewer flavanols remained, and the decline was linear and predictable.
In the same year researchers from the University of Barcelona (Andrés-Lacueva et al.) tested cocoa powders from Spanish shops. In alkalised cocoa the average flavonoid content was 60% lower than in natural cocoa. Both studies looked at powders, but they show clearly how much the process itself changes, a process ceremonial cacao never goes through.
Why is ceremonial cacao thicker and more filling?
Because the cacao butter stays in it. The butter gives the velvety texture and the full, long taste. A drink made from powder is thinner, because most of the fat went to the cosmetics and chocolate industries.
Cacao mass also contains theobromine, a natural alkaloid related to caffeine. Its proportion in powder is different, because the whole composition of the product changes.
How to recognise ceremonial cacao from the ingredients
- There is a single ingredient: cacao mass, cacao liquor or cacao paste.
- There is no sugar, milk powder, lecithin, flavouring or alkali.
- The product comes as a block, discs or flakes that break with a snap.
- The producer states the country the beans come from.
If the package says "reduced-fat cocoa", it is powder, not cacao mass. If the first ingredient is sugar, it is drinking chocolate.
What about raw cacao, nibs and cacao butter?
- Raw cacao is made from unroasted beans or beans roasted at a low temperature. It can be cacao mass, powder or nibs.
- Nibs are crushed, shelled cacao beans. They are crunchy and bitter and good for sprinkling on desserts.
- Cacao butter is the fat alone, separated from the mass. It has a delicate cacao scent and is used in the kitchen and in cosmetics.
Which cacao should you choose?
For baking a cake, cocoa powder is enough. For a quick, sweet drink for children, drinking chocolate. For a calm ritual and full flavour, only ceremonial cacao. How to prepare it is described in our article what is ceremonial cacao and how to prepare it, and how to hold a ceremony at home in a cacao ceremony at home.
It is worth comparing the two drinks side by side: one cup made from powder and one from cacao mass. The difference is clear from the first sip. In our ceremonial cacao category you will find cacao mass from several countries, for example Dominicalm from the Dominican Republic.
Cacao naturally contains theobromine and a small amount of caffeine. If you are pregnant, breastfeeding or take medication regularly, consult your doctor. Keep cacao out of reach of dogs and cats.
Frequently asked questions
Can ceremonial cacao be replaced with dark chocolate?
Only partly. Dark chocolate contains sugar and extra cacao butter, so the drink will be sweeter and taste different. For a ceremony it is better to use pure cacao mass.
Is ceremonial cacao suitable for baking?
Yes, but it has to be melted first. It cannot replace powder one to one in recipes, because it contains much more fat.
Why does ceremonial cacao cost more than powder?
Because it is the whole bean, not what is left after pressing out the butter. Add to that the choice of varieties and handwork. Since 2024 world cacao prices have been very high.
Is cocoa powder a worse product?
Not worse, just different. It is excellent for baking. For drinking in a ritual, it simply does not give the same thickness and fullness of flavour.
Sources
- Miller K.B., Hurst W.J., Payne M.J. et al. (2008). Impact of alkalization on the antioxidant and flavanol content of commercial cocoa powders. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 56(18): 8527-8533.
- Andrés-Lacueva C., Monagas M., Khan N. et al. (2008). Flavanol and flavonol contents of cocoa powder products: influence of the manufacturing process. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 56(9): 3111-3117.