A mushroom extract is a preparation in which the substances locked in a mushroom's tissue have been transferred into a solution: water, a traditional tincture extract, or both in turn. The key distinction concerns what happens to the mushroom: ground dried mushroom is still the same mushroom, only broken up, while an extract is a mushroom from which something has been drawn out. Fungal cell walls are built of chitin, the same hard material that forms insect shells. Grinding alone does not open it. Only long simmering or maceration does, and that is the difference between a powder and an extract.
How does a mushroom extract differ from ground dried mushroom?
Take a piece of varnished conk. It is a hard, woody bracket fungus that nobody would cook like chanterelles. Ground into powder it remains woody, because chitin resists ordinary grinding. That is why in Chinese and Korean cuisine such mushrooms have for centuries gone not onto the plate but into the pot, where a thick, bitter decoction took shape over hours.
An extract is a modern, more carefully conducted continuation of that decoction. The raw material is simmered or macerated, the liquid is separated from the fibres, and the residue, the exhausted tissue, is discarded. What remains in the bottle is what dissolved during the process. Powder from dried mushroom contains everything, including indigestible chitin. An extract contains less matter, but in a more accessible form. They are two different products, not two versions of the same thing.
Where did the tradition of extracting mushrooms come from?
The oldest known evidence of the human relationship with bracket fungi comes from the Alps. Ötzi, the iceman of about 5,300 years ago, carried two species of wood-growing fungi: Fomitopsis betulina (the birch polypore), threaded on a leather thong, and Fomes fomentarius (the tinder fungus), used as tinder for lighting fire. Mycologists described this find in 1998, and since then it has been the starting point for conversations about European knowledge of fungi.
In Poland the tinder fungus served for centuries above all as fire-starting material, hence the Polish word "hubka", tinder. Further east, in Russia, Siberia and the Baltic countries, a dark infusion drunk like tea was made from growths of Inonotus obliquus, the chaga that grows on birches. In China lingzhi, Ganoderma lucidum, was already recorded in the classical herbal Shennong Bencao Jing among the most highly prized materials. Tibetan texts of the 15th century in turn mention Ophiocordyceps sinensis, a fungus growing from moth larvae on high-mountain meadows. Lion's mane, Hericium erinaceus, was meanwhile a delicacy of Chinese cuisine called "monkey head".
The common denominator of these traditions is simple: hard and bitter mushrooms were simmered, soaked and strained. An extract is a continuation of this practice, not a departure from it.
Fruiting body or mycelium: which part is the extract made from?
The fruiting body is the part visible to the naked eye: the cap, the bracket on a trunk, the white, fringed ball of lion's mane. It is fruiting bodies that were gathered in each of the traditions described. The mycelium is a network of fine threads hidden in wood or soil, and in industrial cultivation it often grows through cooked cereal grain.
Both parts belong to the same organism, but they differ in composition. Mycelium grown on grain is sometimes dried and ground together with the substrate, so a large part of such a powder comes from oats or rice. There is nothing wrong with this as long as the producer says so plainly, but it is a different category from an extract of the fruiting body. The question "what is this made from?" is worth asking with every mushroom product.
Cordyceps is a special case. Wild Ophiocordyceps sinensis is rare, expensive and harvested from fragile Himalayan ecosystems. That is why modern extracts are usually made from Cordyceps militaris, a related species whose orange fruiting bodies can be cultivated under controlled conditions.
What is a water extract, and what is a dual extract?
A water extract is the closest relative of the old decoction. The raw material is simmered for a long time in water, which draws out polysaccharides well, including the beta-glucans that build the mushroom's cell wall. This is how chaga was treated in Siberia and lingzhi in China.
Some of a mushroom's compounds, above all the bitter triterpenes typical of reishi and chaga, pass poorly into water alone. That is why many workshops combine two methods. First the raw material undergoes a long maceration by the traditional tincture extract method, then it is simmered in water, and the two liquids are combined into one. This is how a dual extract is made, which covers a wider spectrum of substances than either phase alone.
Not every species needs both stages. With lion's mane and cordyceps the water phase usually predominates, while with reishi and chaga the second phase makes more sense, because they are rich in triterpenes. A well-described product tells you which path it took.
Which species most often go into liquid extracts?
Four mushrooms appear most often in workshops, and each has its own character that you can sense already in the scent and colour of the extract.
- Lion's mane (Hericium erinaceus): mild, slightly sweetish, associated more with the kitchen than with the herbalist's medicine chest. It grows on weakened beeches and oaks and is a protected species in Poland, so the raw material comes from cultivation. You will find our liquid extract as lion's mane extract.
- Varnished conk, reishi (Ganoderma lucidum): distinctly bitter, with a reddish-brown, varnished cap. In Asia it is traditionally used as a mushroom of calm and longevity. See reishi extract.
- Cordyceps (Cordyceps militaris): orange, club-shaped fruiting bodies with a mildly earthy taste. In Himalayan tradition it is associated with the strength of high-mountain herders. Available as liquid cordyceps extract.
- Chaga, the clinker polypore (Inonotus obliquus): a black, cracked growth on birch, with a note reminiscent of vanilla and bark. A mushroom of the north, closest to our climate. See chaga extract.
How to store a liquid extract so that it keeps its character
Liquid mushroom extracts dislike light, heat and air. Dark glass, most often amber or violet, protects the contents from UV radiation, so the bottle is not worth decanting into clear vessels. The best place is a cupboard away from the cooker and the windowsill, at a steady, moderate temperature.
The dropper should go back into the bottle clean and dry, and the cap should be screwed on fully. A light sediment at the bottom is a natural phenomenon in fruiting body extracts: it is particles of polysaccharides that precipitate over time. A change of smell to sour or musty, however, is a sign that the product has lost its freshness.
How to tell whether an extract was made with respect for the forest
The popularity of wood-growing fungi has its price. Chaga grows very slowly, and its excessive gathering in some regions of Scandinavia and Russia has depleted local sites. Wild Himalayan cordyceps has become the object of such intensive harvesting that it affects the meadows and the communities that depend on it.
That is why it is worth paying attention to three things: whether the producer gives the Latin name of the species, whether they say where the raw material comes from (cultivation or gathering from natural sites), and whether they indicate which part of the mushroom went into the extract. At Las Szamana we treat this information as a form of respect both for the forest and for the person who reaches for the bottle.
What did beta-glucan measurements show?
In 2016 Barry McCleary and Anna Draga of the Irish company Megazyme described in the Journal of AOAC International a precise method for measuring beta-glucans that separates them from starch. They used it to test mushroom fruiting bodies and products made from mycelium grown on grain. There were clearly more beta-glucans in fruiting bodies, while in some products made from mycelium on cereal grain alpha-glucans predominated, that is, starch from the substrate. That is why, if I were you, I would always check whether an extract was made from the fruiting body, and look on the label for the name of the method by which beta-glucans were measured.
Other mushrooms from our forest shelf
Every mushroom has its own story. If you want to get to know more of them, take a look at our articles:
- Reishi, the varnished conk of European forests and the lingzhi of China (extract)
- Chaga, the black birch growth known to the peoples of the North (extract)
- Chaga tea, how to brew it and what it tastes like
- Lion's mane, protected in the forest, cultivated on wood (extract)
- Cordyceps, the fungus that grows from a caterpillar (extract)
- Coriolus, turkey tail from the European forest (extract)
- Agaricus, the almond mushroom from Brazilian meadows (extract)
- Maitake, the dancing mushroom of the oaks (extract)
- Shiitake, the mushroom from the oak log (extract)
- Tremella, the snow fungus, the silver ear of China (extract)
- Adaptogenic mushrooms, species, tradition and extraction methods
What questions about mushroom extracts come up most often?
Is an extract the same as mushroom powder?
No. Powder is the ground mushroom together with hard chitin. An extract is a liquid into which compounds drawn out by simmering or maceration have passed, while the exhausted tissue has been discarded.
How do I know whether an extract was made from the fruiting body?
A good description says so plainly. If the label gives only the species name without indicating the part of the mushroom, it is worth asking the producer.
Does sediment at the bottom of the bottle mean a defect?
No. It is naturally precipitated polysaccharides, typical of fruiting body extracts. A gentle shake of the bottle is enough.
If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or take medication regularly, consult a doctor before use.
Sources
- McCleary B.V., Draga A. (2016). Measurement of β-Glucan in Mushrooms and Mycelial Products. Journal of AOAC International 99(2): 364-373.
- Peintner U., Pöder R., Pümpel T. (1998). The iceman's fungi. Mycological Research 102(10): 1153-1162.